Skyway Roofing vs Bruno Massaro & Sons: which fits a roof replacement job?
Both businesses score well overall, but for a roof replacement or installation specifically, only one of these two actually does that work. This comparison, built using our methodology, weighs the data against what matters for tear-offs, roof-deck repair, and full roof installs rather than general remodeling quality.
The differences that matter
- Core trade match. Skyway Roofing is a roofing and gutter specialist doing tear-offs and full replacements in-house, while Bruno Massaro & Sons is built around plaster, drywall, and ceiling/water-damage repair with no roofing work mentioned in its record.
- Track record on the actual job. Skyway's review history is full of specifics on roof replacements (one-day completions, insurance claims, tear-off through install), whereas Bruno Massaro's praise is entirely about interior plaster and drywall craftsmanship.
- Crew and experience for roofing. Skyway names on-site roofing leaders (Elvin, Cody, Darryl, Jesse) and cites over 35 years in the roofing trade, a depth of roofing-specific experience Bruno Massaro's listing does not claim.
- Reliability caveats. Skyway has two recent one-star reviews over missed appointments and communication lapses, a real but isolated issue against an otherwise strong record, while Bruno Massaro shows no complaints at all, though that record is from interior repair work, not roofing.
Side by side
- Google rating
- Skyway Roofing: 4.9 (336 reviews)
- Bruno Massaro & Sons Inc: 5 (150 reviews)
- Services
- Skyway Roofing: roof repair, metal roofing, roof replacement installation, roof inspection gutters
- Bruno Massaro & Sons Inc: roof repair, roof replacement installation, commercial roofing, roofing contractor
- Roofing specialization
- Skyway Roofing: Yes: roofing and gutters, in-house crews, insurance claim support
- Bruno Massaro & Sons Inc: No: plaster, drywall, ceiling and water-damage repair, not roofing
- Best for
- Skyway Roofing: Full roof tear-off, replacement, or new installation
- Bruno Massaro & Sons Inc: Interior ceiling/wall restoration and plaster work in older homes
- Verification
- Skyway Roofing: Google-verified
- Bruno Massaro & Sons Inc: Google-verified
- Composite score
- Skyway Roofing: 90
- Bruno Massaro & Sons Inc: 92
Within 3 points of each other, so treat them as effectively tied on overall quality. The choice below is about fit, not the score.
What reviewers say
Skyway Roofing
Most jobs finish in a single day with no mess left behind. Owners oversee projects, crew arrives on time, and pricing holds up against competing quotes. Two recent no-shows (one without any call for 90 minutes) underscore communication gaps that marred an otherwise stellar track record, though such failures remain rare among 336 reviews.
Staff including Jesse, Cody, Darryl, and Elvin handle roofing, gutters, windows, and siding in-house. The family has operated over 35 years across four counties. Reviewers praise the owners for high integrity-one turned away unnecessary work. Quotes are detailed; estimates described as fair to competitive.
Bruno Massaro & Sons Inc
Owners and landlords consistently report perfect results on water-damaged ceilings and old plaster repairs, with crews leaving spaces spotless and damage undetectable months later. Staff communicate clearly throughout multi-day projects, handle tricky jobs like lath restoration and popcorn removal, and price transparently with no hidden fees.
Which should you pick?
Pick Skyway Roofing if
- You need a tear-off and full roof replacement or new installation
- You want an in-house roofing crew with named leaders and decades of roofing-specific experience
- You may need help navigating an insurance claim for storm or damage-related roof work
Pick Bruno Massaro & Sons Inc if
- You actually need interior plaster, drywall, or ceiling repair, not roofing
- You're restoring an older home's plaster walls or ceilings and want proven craftsmanship in that specific trade
- Your project involves water-damage repair to ceilings rather than the roof itself
Verdict
For roof replacement and installation, Skyway Roofing is the only real fit here. Bruno Massaro & Sons has a stronger composite score and a flawless review record, but that record is built entirely on plaster and drywall work, not roofing. Skyway brings the actual trade experience, in-house crews, and job-specific track record (tear-offs, one-day replacements, insurance claims) that this job calls for. Just confirm scheduling details up front given the isolated no-show complaints in its recent reviews.
Need help deciding which contractor to hire?
Describe your roofing job once and compare quotes from suitable roofing contractor in Greater Hartford.
Enquiries submitted through our contact forms may be shared with partner providers to carry out the work, and we may earn a referral fee from those referrals. Our rankings and scores are determined independently by our published method and are never influenced by referral fees.
FAQ
- Does Bruno Massaro & Sons do roof replacements?
- Nothing in its review record or listed specialties mentions roofing work. Its praise and expertise center on plaster, drywall, ceiling repair, and water damage restoration, not roof tear-offs or installs.
- Is Skyway Roofing reliable despite the one-star reviews?
- The bulk of its record shows strong performance on actual roof replacements, with named crew leaders and over 35 years of roofing experience. The two one-star reviews cite missed appointments, worth asking about directly when scheduling.
- Which business has the higher composite score?
- Bruno Massaro & Sons scores 92.6 versus Skyway's 90.2, but that score reflects strength in a different trade (interior plaster/drywall), not roofing.